Iii. California Supreme Court Holds First Teleconference Oral Argument After Covid-19 Shelter-in-place Order

Anecdotally, the Court sought unanimity in some selections (similar to Brown and United States v. Nixon) to be able to give the choice larger power. The vote margin of an opinion could affect its rate of future citations. In addition to the ideological homogeneity speculation, some argue that the number of Justices in the majority, regardless of their ideological positions, will influence the significance of a Supreme Court opinion. The number of Justices becoming a member of a majority may be considered related to its authorized authority.

In addition to the above determinants, we consider extra control variables, which might influence the power of an opinion in future citations and correlate with our different independent variables of curiosity. The first of those is the variety of amici who be part of the case before the Supreme Court, known as Amici.

There are a few surprising variations between the uncooked variety of Supreme Court citations and the authority score that builds on these citations. Liberal opinions and rulings on constitutional issues have significantly higher authority scores but not significantly more direct citations. They apparently produce opinions which might be cited by circumstances that are themselves more necessary.

A study of circuit courtroom opinions found that reversals had been considerably longer than affirmances. Yet a rule would not be anticipated to have less power within the law than would a extra discretionary standard. Different forms of courts are inclined … Read More