Advance Opinions

court opinions

Citing Court Opinions (Also Known As “Case Citations”)

7, seventy three (“The [opinion] construed the Fourteenth Amendment in an absurdly slim method, which has been roundly excoriated by courts and students.”). See Gerhardt, supra observe 70, at 1207–08; Sinclair, supra note 70, at 364.

Pennsylvania Commonwealth Court’s Opportunity Zone Ruling Favors Law Firm

Table 1 sets out the listing of high cases by simple variety of citations the opinion has received. We construct upon these earlier studies on this analysis, through the use of further measures and finding out the characteristics of an important opinions. While it is no shock that opinions are not equal, current empirical analysis has largely treated them as in the event that they were. Opinions are judged simply by binary outcomes, based mostly upon who gained or lost the case.

The seventh case, Apprendi v. New Jersey, could replicate a slightly totally different impact that could possibly be distinguished from case significance. This opinion was extremely disruptive of current law, holding that factual determinations underlying criminal sentencing require a jury’s determination. This claim could also be a bit too robust because a very unworkable choice on these matters would prove unhelpful to lower courts and presumably result in one other Court determination creating a greater precedent. However, even a moderately good determination, workable on the decrease court degree, would not essentially want overruling or revision. Any main Supreme Court choice on these questions could properly be highly cited.

For example, Cantwell is above the 99th … Read More